The family holiday home is one of the most emotionally charged assets anyone can inherit. It holds decades of memories — summer barbecues, children’s first swims, New Year gatherings around the fireplace. Yet for a growing number of families across Europe and the United States, inheriting that beloved property is becoming less a gift and more a burden. Rising maintenance costs, punitive inheritance taxes, sibling disagreements over usage, and the sheer complexity of multi-generational ownership are turning once-treasured homes into sources of family conflict and financial strain.
According to Keystone Law, inherited property disputes between siblings are among the fastest-growing areas of estate litigation, with disagreements over whether to sell, rent, or keep a property frequently tearing families apart. Meanwhile, UK homeowners now spend an average of £627 per month on home maintenance alone, according to Property Business Insights — a figure that doubles or triples for holiday properties in premium locations. The result? A generation of families asking a very different question: is there a smarter way to own a holiday home? The answer increasingly points to co-ownership — and specifically, the LLC-based fractional model that eliminates the inheritance trap entirely.
The Problem
Why Inherited Holiday Homes Become Family Battlegrounds
The romantic notion of passing down a holiday home rarely survives first contact with reality. When a property transfers to two, three, or four siblings, each with different financial situations, usage expectations, and life priorities, conflict is almost inevitable. One sibling may want to sell immediately to release capital, while another insists on keeping the home for sentimental reasons. A third might live closest and end up shouldering a disproportionate share of the maintenance, breeding resentment that can persist for decades.
Research from Hackard Law shows that inheritance disputes involving shared property are among the most emotionally destructive forms of family litigation, often resurfacing decades of sibling rivalry and unresolved tensions. The financial dimension compounds the emotional one: shared ownership of a single property means shared liability for repairs, insurance, property taxes, and management — yet rarely does every co-owner contribute equally or use the property fairly.
In France, the situation is further complicated by forced heirship laws (réserve héréditaire), which require that between 50% and 75% of an estate pass to the deceased’s children, regardless of the owner’s wishes. According to the Notaires de France, this means you cannot simply leave your French holiday home to a chosen beneficiary — the law dictates who inherits, and at what proportion. For foreign owners unaware of these rules, the consequences can be devastating.
The co-ownership model used by Co-Ownership Property is built on a fundamentally different legal architecture that sidesteps virtually every inheritance problem described above. Instead of owning bricks and mortar directly, each co-owner holds shares in a registered LLC (Limited Liability Company) that owns the property. This single structural difference transforms the entire inheritance picture.
LLC shares are classified as movable assets (meubles) in most legal systems — not immovable real estate. This distinction is critical. In France, for example, the forced heirship rules that apply to physical property do not apply in the same way to movable company shares held by non-residents, according to analysis by French-Property.com. The shares can be transferred, gifted, or bequeathed with far greater flexibility than a direct property interest.
From a tax perspective, the advantages are equally compelling. The IRS recognises that minority, non-controlling interests in an LLC can be valued at a significant discount — sometimes as much as 30-40% below the proportional asset value — because a minority share lacks both control and marketability. This means that when shares are transferred as part of estate planning, the taxable value of the gift or inheritance can be substantially lower than the underlying property value. According to Kiplinger, this valuation discount is one of the most powerful estate planning tools available to property-owning families.
| Country | Forced Heirship? | Succession Tax (Direct Heirs) | LLC/SCI Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| France | Yes — 50-75% reserved for children | 5% to 45% (progressive) | SCI shares = movable property; can bypass forced heirship for non-residents |
| Spain | Yes — varies by region | 7.65% to 34% (varies by community) | Corporate structure shields from regional variation; easier cross-border transfer |
| Italy | Yes — 33-66% reserved | 4% to 8% (with allowances) | LLC shares simplify multi-heir distribution; avoid co-ownership deadlocks |
| United Kingdom | No forced heirship | 40% above £325,000 | No main residence relief for second homes; LLC offers valuation flexibility |
| United States | No (except Louisiana) | 40% above $13.6M (2024) | LLC minority discount of 30-40%; exemption set to halve from 2026 |
Practical Advantages
From Sibling Disputes to Seamless Succession: Co-Ownership in Practice
The practical benefits of co-ownership extend far beyond legal structure. When a family member who holds a 1/8th share in a co-owned property passes away or wishes to transfer their share, the process is straightforward. The LLC’s operating agreement typically gives existing co-owners first right of refusal to purchase the share at market value. If they decline, the share is listed for sale to external buyers — with an average resale time of around one month, compared to the 6-12 months typical for full property sales.
This means that inheritance never forces remaining family members into an unwanted, indefinite co-ownership arrangement with relatives who want out. Every share has a clear, market-determined value and a liquid exit path. There is no need for partition lawsuits, no forced sales at below-market prices, and no decades-long standoffs between siblings who disagree on the property’s future.
Equally important, the professional management structure eliminates the “who pays for repairs” problem that plagues inherited properties. All running costs — maintenance, insurance, property taxes, cleaning, administration — are split proportionately among shareholders and managed centrally. No single family member is left chasing contributions from reluctant relatives. Learn more about the running costs of co-ownership and how they compare to full ownership.
Understanding the inheritance landscape is essential whether you’re buying a new co-ownership share or planning what to do with an existing property. The rules vary dramatically by jurisdiction, and getting them wrong can cost families hundreds of thousands in avoidable taxes and legal fees. The table below summarises the key differences across the most popular holiday home destinations.
What becomes immediately clear from any cross-border comparison is that direct property ownership is the most legally exposed form of holding a holiday home. Every jurisdiction applies its own succession rules to physical real estate within its borders. By contrast, shares in an LLC or equivalent corporate structure benefit from the legal characterisation as movable property — which in many cases means they are governed by the law of the owner’s domicile, not the property’s location. This is one of the most compelling reasons to explore fractional ownership through a properly structured entity.
The Bigger Picture
Co-Ownership as a Modern Family Wealth Strategy
The shift towards co-ownership is part of a broader rethinking of how affluent families approach property. The traditional model — buy a holiday home, use it three weeks a year, pay full running costs, and hope the next generation wants it — is increasingly seen as inefficient and risky. A Knight Frank Wealth Report found that high-net-worth individuals are prioritising flexibility and liquidity over outright ownership, with the number of UHNWIs holding second homes declining even as travel spending increases.
Co-ownership aligns perfectly with this shift. A 1/8th share delivers approximately 45 days of usage per year — more than most full owners actually use their holiday homes — at a fraction of the purchase price and running costs. The property is professionally managed, beautifully maintained, and your personal belongings are stored and unpacked for every visit. When it’s time to pass the share to the next generation, the legal and financial pathway is clear, simple, and tax-efficient.
For families who already own a holiday home and are facing the inheritance question, the calculus is worth examining carefully. Selling the family property and reinvesting the proceeds across two or three co-ownership shares in different destinations can give each family member their own independent share — eliminating shared ownership conflicts entirely while diversifying the family’s property exposure across co-ownership destinations in multiple countries.
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I leave my co-ownership share to my children in my will?
Yes. Because you own shares in an LLC (or SCI in France) rather than a direct property interest, your shares can be bequeathed through your will like any other financial asset. The LLC operating agreement may include right-of-first-refusal provisions for existing co-owners, but these are designed to facilitate smooth transitions, not block inheritance.
Do French forced heirship rules apply to co-ownership shares?
For non-residents of France, shares in an SCI or LLC are classified as movable property (meubles) rather than immovable real estate. This classification generally means that French forced heirship rules do not apply in the same restrictive way as they would for direct property ownership. However, individual circumstances vary, and professional legal advice is always recommended.
How is a co-ownership share valued for inheritance tax purposes?
LLC shares are valued at their fair market value, but minority, non-controlling interests typically qualify for valuation discounts of 30-40% in the United States. This means the taxable value of the share can be significantly lower than its proportional share of the property’s total value. European valuations follow similar principles, though discount levels vary by jurisdiction.
What happens if one co-owner dies — do I end up sharing with their heirs?
The LLC operating agreement governs what happens when a co-owner dies. Typically, existing co-owners have the first right to purchase the deceased’s share at market value. If they choose not to, the share passes to the designated heirs. In all cases, the property management continues uninterrupted — there is no need for the remaining co-owners to interact directly with the estate.
Is co-ownership better than setting up a family trust for my holiday home?
The two approaches serve different purposes and can be complementary. A family trust controls who benefits from your assets and when, while an LLC co-ownership structure provides professional property management, clear valuation, and a liquid exit. Many families combine both — holding their co-ownership shares within a trust for maximum estate planning flexibility.
Can I gift my co-ownership share to my children during my lifetime?
Absolutely. Gifting shares during your lifetime is often more tax-efficient than leaving them as an inheritance. In the US, you can use the annual gift tax exclusion ($18,000 per recipient in 2024). In France, each parent can gift up to €100,000 per child every 15 years without triggering gift tax. Gradual gifting also allows you to retain a partial stake while progressively transferring ownership.
Get in Touch
Speak to an expert
Tell us what you're looking for and one of our co-ownership specialists will be in touch within 24 hours.